Originally published July 12, 2025. Republished here as part of the author’s canonical professional archive.
In the United States today, it has become increasingly common to see the federal government act as a central authority with near-unilateral control over policy decisions ranging from education and healthcare to environmental regulations and infrastructure. Yet, this modern conception of a dominant federal power stands in stark contrast to the foundational vision of the American republic.
Contrary to current practice, the federal government was never intended to exist as an independent sovereign over the states. Rather, it was created by the states, to serve their collective interests, as they in turn serve the people. To preserve liberty, promote responsiveness, and respect the consent of the governed, we must reaffirm this constitutional order: the people direct the states, and the states direct the federal government, not the reverse.
The Chain of Delegated Authority
The founding structure of the American republic is built on the notion of delegated authority. Sovereignty begins with the people, who cede some of their powers to state governments, which are geographically, culturally, and socially closer to them. In turn, the states voluntarily delegated specific powers to the federal government, not as a superior entity, but as a servant of mutual interests such as defense, foreign policy, and interstate commerce.
This is not a speculative interpretation. The original governing document of the United States, the Articles of Confederation, plainly declared that:
“Each state retains its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, and every power, jurisdiction, and right, which is not by this Confederation expressly delegated to the United States” (Articles of Confederation, 1781, art. II).
Though the Articles proved inadequate in creating a functional national government, this foundational principle of state sovereignty carried forward into the Constitution. The Tenth Amendment, added as part of the Bill of Rights to protect this understanding, reads:
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people” (U.S. Const. amend. X).
This amendment underscores the idea that the federal government has only the powers expressly granted by the Constitution, while all remaining authority rests with the states or the people. It is a principle of limited, enumerated powers — not open-ended federal prerogative.
The Founders’ Original Intent: A Limited Central Authority
The framers of the Constitution were acutely aware of the dangers of centralized power. Having just thrown off the rule of a distant monarch, they designed a system that placed power as close to the people as possible, distributing it across the states and restricting the authority of the federal government.
In Federalist №45, James Madison, often referred to as the “Father of the Constitution”, wrote:
“The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite” (Madison, 1788).
Madison understood that the Constitution created a government of limited jurisdiction, not a national authority with a blank check to involve itself in every aspect of governance. The states were not mere administrative units of a federal empire; they were coequal members of a voluntary compact.
Thomas Jefferson, in his Kentucky Resolutions of 1798, expressed concern that federal overreach would lead to tyranny. He wrote:
“The government created by this compact was not made the exclusive or final judge of the extent of the powers delegated to itself” (Jefferson, 1798/2005, para. 3).
For Jefferson, the Constitution was a contract among states, and any attempt by the federal government to unilaterally expand its powers violated that compact.
Even President George Washington, in his 1796 farewell address, warned against the consolidation of power in the federal government:
“It is important… that the general government should be considered as the result of a compact… and that every encroachment upon it… is to be regarded as a usurpation” (Washington, 1796/2000, para. 12).
These were not radical statements, they reflected a common understanding of federalism that placed the states in the driver’s seat of the republic.
Federalism Beyond Our Borders: Comparative Models
This model of subsidiarity, where decisions are made at the lowest appropriate level, is echoed in other democratic systems. In Germany, for instance, the Basic Law (Grundgesetz) outlines a clear division between federal and state authority, explicitly stating that the federal government may only legislate where the Basic Law confers that authority (Grundgesetz, Art. 70–74). German Länder (states) hold significant power, particularly in education, law enforcement, and cultural affairs.
Similarly, Canada’s Constitution Act of 1867 establishes the division of powers between the federal Parliament and the provincial legislatures, with specific powers reserved for each. Provinces control matters such as property, civil rights, and local affairs (Hogg, 2007). In both systems, the federal government exists to coordinate, not to control.
This international context illustrates that the principle of federalism is not antiquated or uniquely American, it is a cornerstone of modern democratic governance. Local governments, including states or provinces, are better suited to respond to the needs of their populations. When power is decentralized, people are more empowered and institutions are more accountable.
How the Inversion Happened
Despite the clear original framework, the 20th and 21st centuries have seen a steady centralization of power in Washington, D.C. Key turning points include the New Deal era, when the federal government vastly expanded its economic role; the civil rights era, when federal authority was used to override state-sanctioned discrimination (justifiably in many cases); and the post-9/11 period, when federal agencies gained sweeping surveillance and security powers.
But what began as temporary expansions often became permanent federal domains. Today, federal agencies regulate education (Department of Education), healthcare (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services), agriculture, housing, environmental standards, and even local policing. Entire swaths of governance that once belonged to the states now operate under federal mandates, often with little input from those most affected.
While some federal interventions have served noble causes, the net effect has been to transform the federal government from servant to master, from a delegate of the states to an enforcer of uniform national policy. This inversion of power violates both the letter and the spirit of the Constitution.
Why This Matters Today
At its core, the problem is philosophical as well as a legal one. If the federal government is seen as the highest authority, then the people’s influence is diminished, as their most direct representatives, state and local governments, are relegated to implementing federal policy instead of shaping it.
This matters in practical terms. States are diverse in culture, economy, geography, and values. What works in Massachusetts may not work in Mississippi. When Washington imposes one-size-fits-all policies, it strips states of their ability to innovate, experiment, and respond to local needs.
It also erodes political accountability. When decisions are made by distant federal agencies, citizens are less able to influence them. But if those decisions are made at the state level, voters have more power to demand change, elect new leaders, and assert their will.
A Return to Constitutional Order
Restoring constitutional federalism does not require abolishing the federal government or weakening national unity. It means reasserting the proper order of authority:
- The People are sovereign.
- They express that sovereignty through their state governments.
- The states, acting on behalf of their citizens, direct the federal government on how to serve collective national interests, such as defense, diplomacy, and interstate commerce.
This is not just a theory, it is the logic of our founding documents, our legal structure, and our democratic principles. As Jefferson wrote:
“When all government, domestic and foreign, in little as in great things, shall be drawn to Washington as the center of all power, it will render powerless the checks of one government upon another” (Jefferson, 1821/1984, p. 159).
If we fail to restore that balance, we risk not only inefficiency but also tyranny, the very condition the Constitution was written to prevent.
Conclusion: From the People, Through the States
The federal government is not a sovereign entity unto itself. It is a creation of the states, which are themselves instruments of the people. To reverse this order is to subvert the very foundation of our republic.
In reclaiming our constitutional structure, we must remember: The people are not subjects of the federal government. The states are not vassals of Washington. The federal government is a tool, created, controlled, and directed by the states to serve the people.
References
Articles of Confederation. (1781). U.S. Government Archives. https://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?flash=false&doc=3
Grundgesetz für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany], Art. 70–74 (1949).
Hogg, P. W. (2007). Constitutional Law of Canada (5th ed.). Thomson Carswell.
Jefferson, T. (2005). The Kentucky Resolutions of 1798. In M. Vile (Ed.), Documents of American Constitutional and Legal History (Vol. 1, pp. 145–147). Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1798)
Jefferson, T. (1984). The Writings of Thomas Jefferson (A. Lipscomb, Ed., Vol. 15). University of Virginia Press. (Original work published 1821)
Madison, J. (1788). Federalist №45: The Alleged Danger From the Powers of the Union to the State Governments Considered. https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed45.asp
U.S. Constitution, amend. X.
Washington, G. (2000). Farewell Address. In L. J. Cappon (Ed.), The Adams-Jefferson Letters (pp. 615–618). UNC Press. (Original work published 1796)